02
25

Activism Works: Racist Billboard Comes Down

by Lisa Bennett, NOW Communications Director

Thanks to widespread public outrage -- including organized efforts by the Women of Color Policy Network and the Trust Black Women Partnership -- an inflammatory billboard lasted just two days in New York City. Paid for by the anti-reproductive rights group Life Always, the billboard showed a young African-American girl with a startling message above her head: "The most dangerous place for an African American is in the womb."

Unveiled on Feb. 23, the three-story tall advertisement was scheduled to hang on a building in lower Manhattan for three weeks, but the company that sold Life Always the space agreed to take it down today.

Trust Black Women spread the word on Facebook that the ad was "offensive, racist, sexist and -- most of all -- disrespectful of our decision making, our 400-year history of raising and caring for black children, and our human right to make health care choices for ourselves."

This billboard is part of a larger strategy that attempts to use disparate abortion rates to shame women of color and discourage them from advocating for reproductive justice. The fact that Life Always used Black History Month as a reference in its press materials makes this tactic even more shameful.

New York City Council Member Letitia James had this to say: "Singling out African-Americans during Black History Month is particularly offensive, and to equate it with genocide and terrorism is really offensive to all New Yorkers."

We only have to look at the current attacks on reproductive health care to see what's going on. Poor and low-income women, of whom a disproportionate amount are women of color, often are the target of legislative efforts to curb access to abortion and all forms of family planning. And a lack of access to contraception can and does result in unplanned pregnancies.

The National Latina Institute for Reproductive Health, which also spoke out against the billboard, stated: "Studies show that African American women and Latinas are more likely to be uninsured or underinsured and often lack basic access to birth control and comprehensive sex education due to fundamental structural inequities in society."

Trust Black Women notes: "The disparity in abortion rates mirrors all other health care disparities in the black community from heart disease to infant mortality and diabetes. To isolate abortion as if it is not a part of health care is disrespectful and ill-informed. These disparities speak to root causes too often overlooked when talking about the black community: 'a long history of racism, lack of access to high-quality, affordable health care, too few educational and professional opportunities, unequal access to safe, clean neighborhoods, and for some…a lingering mistrust of the medical community.'" [internal quote from physician Melissa Gilliam]

As we fight these assaults on reproductive rights, we must remember that women of color and low-income women are often the first and most affected by the radical right's war on women. Stopping this war will save lives and empower women -- something the group behind the billboard doesn't want you to know.

10 comments » Register or log in to leave a comment. [Log in] [Register...]

Comment from: Margo [Member] Email
The numbers don't lie. I think nearly anyone with a social conscious feels that the number of abortions nation-wide is sickening, and more so in the African-American community. Do a little background on the racist Planned Parenthood founder, Margaret Sanger. "Human weeds," she calls poor populations. But it is possible to be pro-woman, pro-African American, and pro-life. The billboard had a profound, if unpopular, message.
02/27/11 @ 14:19
Report Abuse

Comment from: Butler [Member] Email
Indeed, the numbers don't lie. Every abortion represents an occasion when a man chose not to contracept.
02/27/11 @ 21:57
Report Abuse

Comment from: letsbefair [Member] Email
Butler, what an astonishingly sexist thing to say. Last I checked, ladies contribute a cell as well.

Margo has a fair point. Poverty rates - which are obviously high among African Americans and other minorities - lead to high rates of abortion as well. This doesn't make them socially advanced as a demographic: it actually leaves them behind. There is strength in numbers (ESPECIALLY in democracy), but numbers will shrink as poverty and abortion rates grow.

But that's right...I'd forgotten that NOW often identifies with the majority who hold the social power and privilege.
02/28/11 @ 01:37
Report Abuse

Comment from: whittey [Member] Email
Some comment strings have loading optional; if mostly trolls, as above, are posting, that might be a good option.
If a woman can't decide when or whether to bear a child, it's a good deal like slavery. The aim of Right to (run your) Life groups is clear when they oppose birth control.
Exposure of these forces at
http://revcom.us/a/223/abortion-en.html

The Morality of the Right to Abortion... And the Immorality of Those Who Oppose It
03/01/11 @ 18:09
Report Abuse

Comment from: letsbefair [Member] Email
@Whittey: so none are now allowed to disagree, discuss, or question the terms of NOW's social engagement? I believe at that point, it ceases to be engagement and begins to be imposition.

As far as your analogy....Comparing pregnancy to slavery is interesting, but most women enter intercourse by choice, and resulting pregnancies are short-term with typically low risk. Slaves did not enter into slavery by choice (by definition), and slavery was long-term with typically high risk. Seriously poor comparison.

This "abortion" war ought to be against nature, if anything, not legislature. Natural selection and survivalism, somewhere hundreds of millions of years ago, decided that one sex carries the child and the other doesn't. If that natural designation is what you wish to shed, you have a few basic, fair options: 1) don't have sex (or at least use protection); 2) develop technology that carries babies so women don't have to; 3) allow men the option of a "paper abortion" to supplement the female abortion (men certainly have the ability for self-determination as well don't they?).

It's impossible to determine when a "fetus" will begin to have rights. When it is able to survive outside the womb? When it is born naturally? When it is conceived? When the heart begins to beat? When the brain or nerves begin to function? If we respect those rights for all beings, all clumps of cells that are or will become fully human, it makes the slope a lot less slippery. Let's consider female fetuses - do women have a right before they are born to live? Do men have a similar right?
03/02/11 @ 19:21
Report Abuse

Comment from: moocat [Member] Email
The ad was inflammatory and ugly. Detestable. I absolutely don't appreciate it one bit.

However, I wonder about the wisdom of forcing unpopular beliefs underground when we want the ability to be heard and acknowledged ourselves. I want to see this stuff so I can confront it in the light. Reminds me somewhat of the Atheist billboards, unpopular, cheeky, and disturbing to some. Getting a lot of attention in positive ways.
03/07/11 @ 22:45
Report Abuse

Comment from: betty [Member] Email
The founder of Planned Parenthood was a racist who supported the eugenics movement against non-white and other "undesirables." It is not a coincidence that most of these clinics are in poor black neighborhoods. Now's position on abortion is antiquated. It is now 2011, not 1962. Science tells us that "a person's a person no matter how small." We did not have the science back then. We should know better now.
03/25/11 @ 12:11
Report Abuse

Comment from: troutpout [Member]
Our modern culture has created the nightmare we are all discussing here. I find it interesting that the statement on the billboard: "The most dangerous place for an African American is in the womb." is called, inflammatory. If you don't believe that a baby is a baby at the time of abortion, how could this be disturbing? Doesn't NOW preach how a woman has reproductive rights and she doesn't have to reproduce if she doesn't want to? Maybe there is some kind of undertow need to keep women of color in the dark about the reality of their pregnancies. Maybe Margaret Sanger's ghost wants NOW to hush up ...hmmm. Sad.
04/12/11 @ 22:04
Report Abuse

Comment from: glad_to_be_here [Member]
@letsbefair:

You're so close to the mark this time. Almost there.

option 4: babies get generated in two parts! When each half comes out of each parent, they stick 'em together like legos. Bam, equality!

Can we conclude your limited-imagination thought experiments?
06/15/11 @ 03:58
Report Abuse

Comment from: cherrycheek [Member] Email
I feel so badly about Casey and Caylee Anthony. This is why abortion is so very important, for without it the male reproductive parts will have to be discontinued.
How horrible that a young woman felt that the only way out was to murder her child. I believe that if she was guilty that she needs alot of care and I hate that she did not receive the care before all this tragedy occurred.
Where is the father in all this ? Where are the parents in all this ? Where is the brother in all this ? Where is the american social service system in all this and by God where is the help for Casey and Caylee ?????????
I heard the slut word used and I have the info that the male pop must hear loud and clear !!!!! There are no sluts withour your nasty male repro parts wagging around like dogs !
That felt great to get that out, and now ladies let us make sure the abortions go forward as planned. Reproduction is a sacred thing and we shall decide when to implement it.
07/04/11 @ 07:05
Report Abuse

Comments are not allowed from anonymous visitors.