Watch and Listen Report
03-06-00

 
This weekly report will include NOW's praise and criticism for the previous week in media and our feminist picks for recommended tv shows, movies, magazines and more. We hope that you will keep coming back to this site and keep in touch by sending e-mail to nnt@now.org. Periodically we will print highlights from your comments.  Please give us your full name, city and state if we have permission to quote directly from your letter. 

by Lisa Bennett-Haigney, NOW Publications Manager


Talking Walls Tell Neglected Stories

Four years after HBO's "If These Walls Could Talk" took on the usually taboo subject of abortion and scored huge ratings, the cable movie channel brings us a follow up that addresses lesbian issues.  But the best part is that it's not an "issue" movie and it doesn't lecture on legislation or political agendas.  However, "Walls 2" does make a case for tolerance and equal rights through interesting characters and very personal stories.

Like the first movie, this one is divided into three parts that take place in different times over the last half century. The first part, "1961," is simply amazing – subtle and restrained, yet heartbreaking. Vanessa Redgrave, in a performance you can't forget, plays a retired schoolteacher who, after the loss of her lifetime partner, must cope with the fact that she is now alone and at the same time unrecognized as the aggrieved  spouse. These first 30 minutes or so are like a beautiful short story and really shouldn't be missed.

In "1976" the issues are divisions among feminists and lesbians. Two young women meet, one a dedicated feminist, the other a woman who feels most comfortable in traditional male clothing. Chloe Sevigny (who was great in the movie "Boys Don't Cry") is touching as the "butch" Amy who knows who she is and values her dignity.  Although the lessons in this one seem rather simplistic, the issue is so untouched on TV that it seems fresh and daring. The final segment, "2000," stars Ellen DeGeneres and Sharon Stone as a devoted couple trying to have a baby. This story plays out like a romantic comedy, so it feels much lighter than the other two. But the segment's writer/director, Anne Heche (DeGeneres' partner), handles the subject so frankly and sincerely that many viewers were won over.

As a warning (or another reason to watch, take your pick), fairly explicit sex scenes are included in the last two segments.  These scenes manage to avoid feeling gratuitous and do not come off as entertainment for the guys. One could argue that they succeed in illustrating the characters' passion for each other and expanding upon their personalities. "If These Walls Could Talk 2" shows the progress that has been made over the last 40 years, while touching on what could still be.  By telling these three stories simply and on a small-scale, the three women directors make a big statement.  HBO will be re-running the movie—check your local listings for dates and times. If you appreciate the movie, send HBO a thank you letter.

Perfect Murder, Bad TV

Sweeps month always means at least one true crime movie. This month's dive into scandal was CBS's "Perfect Murder, Perfect Town," a two-parter about murdered 6-year-old JonBenet Ramsey.  It's not enough that the media fixated on the murder of this tiny blonde beauty queen. A movie had to re-create the story that has been talked about and reported on for three years now. What more could be said?  The movie veers between two tracks: the boring and overly detailed in-fights between the police and the DA's office (a confusing cast of around 15 men), and the skin-crawling parts about the murder and the Ramsey family dynamic. The girl's bathroom habits are discussed in a truly creepy scene. And in the autopsy scene, the camera pans up slowly over the girl's body clothed only in underpants, her face a blue death mask. Filmmakers and writers in general demonstrate an obsession with the killings of attractive young women, but "Perfect Murder, Perfect Town" hits an all-time low.  Which leads us to ask: why did the movieget such great ratings?   We can only hope that lots of those viewers felt the same way we did – a strong urge to turn away at the sight of a dead little girl.  The ratings for the second part did drop significantly.  (By the way, this viewer had to watch the movie for NOW's media monitoring project.) Tell CBS to show a little responsibility and taste where crimes against women and especially girls are concerned, or else we all know how to use the remote.

This week's feminist media picks:

(Note:  Nothing is perfect, particularly in our society's media. These picks represent those works of entertainment or information that are for the most part woman-positive and socially responsible.)

Web Site: FAIR (Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting).  Stop by this site for a hard look at the way the news is reported, and what is not reported.  While you're there, visit the Women's Desk for some excellent articles on how women in general and feminists in particular frequently get the short stick from our information providers.  You'll never look at or read the news the same way.

Video Rental:  A Walk on the Moon (1999) directed by Tony Goldwyn, written by Pamela Gray. Released last year, this small movie wasn't a box office blockbuster, but it did receive great reviews and is doing respectable business on video. Diane Lane stars as a young wife spending the summer of 1969 with her family at a resort in the Catskills. While the previously inhibited Lane explores her sexuality with a hippie blouse salesman, her teenage daughter is experiencing her own coming of age. Her decision to run free or remain devoted to her family is painted honestly and compellingly. Gray is a talented writer  with a bright future and all of the performances are honest and brave.  The period music's pretty good, too.

TV Show:  Judging Amy (CBS, Tuesday 10-11pm ET). Last night TV Guide readers awarded "Judging Amy" best new drama and its star, Amy Brenneman, favorite actress in a new series. If you haven't already caught this growing hit, check it out. Brenneman plays a family court judge and her mother, the always powerful Tyne Daly, works in social services, so there's lots of time devoted to serious family issues.  But the family interaction at home is also important and very real.  TV has exhibited a positive trend this season toward growing up and showing smart, strong women (see our recommendations in the last two columns). And viewers have rewarded the networks with good ratings for these new shows. Here's to hoping the trend continues.


NOW Home Page / Join NOW / Catalog/ Search / Send mail to NOW